Skip to content

A Dangerous Health Tech Idea: The Hidden Risks of Sharing Medical Data

Suppose you can get instant medical advice anytime, anywhere.

Sounds amazing, right?

AI chatbots are becoming popular for diagnosing issues and interpreting medical scans.

Well, they promise quick answers and convenience.

But have you thought about the risks?

Sharing sensitive medical data with these tools isn’t always safe.

It raises big concerns about privacy, security, and how accurate these AI tools really are.

In this blog, we’ll uncover some of the hidden dangers of using AI for medical advice.

Plus, we’ll share practical tips to protect your health data and insights for healthtech startups to build safer solutions. Let’s get started!

Why Are Healthcare AI Chatbots So Popular?

AI chatbots are changing the way people access healthcare.

They’re quick, easy to use, and always available. It’s no surprise that more and more people are turning to them for medical advice and information.

For many, the biggest draw is convenience.

AI chatbots offer instant answers without the hassle of booking appointments or waiting in long queues.

Tools like Grok even let users upload X-rays or MRIs to get AI-powered interpretations. This kind of instant access feels empowering, especially for those who need quick insights.

Cost is another big factor.

Traditional healthcare can be expensive, with consultation fees and other charges.

On the other hand, many AI platforms are free or offer affordable subscription plans. This makes them appealing to people looking for budget-friendly options.

Plus, as we rely more on technology, searching for health advice online has become second nature. Chatbots feel like a natural extension of this habit, offering health tips in the same way we’d ask Google a question.

But while the convenience is tempting, it’s important to think about the risks too.

Sharing medical data with these platforms isn’t always safe, and relying on them alone can lead to inaccurate or risky decisions.

AI & Healthcare Data: A Privacy Nightmare

Sharing medical data with AI tools can seem harmless, but it raises serious privacy concerns. Here’s why:

1. Data Shared with Third Parties

When you use AI tools, your medical data might be shared with various companies. These could include service providers, data hosts, and marketers.

For example, Calmara, an app that claims to detect STIs from photos, shares user data with multiple partners. Often, users aren’t aware of who is receiving their data.

2. Risk of Employer Misuse

What happens if your data ends up in the wrong hands?

If a third-party data broker shares your medical info with your employer, it could lead to discrimination. That’s a big concern when it comes to AI-powered healthcare tools.

3. Government Surveillance

Without strong privacy laws for AI, there’s a risk that government agencies could misuse your data.

While HIPAA protects health info, it doesn’t cover everything, especially when AI comes into play.

4. Data Breaches

The healthcare industry has a history of data breaches. In fact, breaches in the first five months of 2022 nearly doubled compared to the previous year.

Worse, some people have found their private health records used in AI training datasets without their consent.

5. Grok’s Privacy Concerns

Take Grok, for example. This AI chatbot encourages users to upload medical images to help improve the AI’s accuracy.

But Grok’s privacy policy says it shares data with related companies, raising questions about how widely your information is being shared.

These examples show how easily sensitive medical data can be exposed or misused when it’s not handled properly.

The Privacy Gap in Non-HIPAA-Covered Apps

Most healthcare apps are not covered by HIPAA, the law that protects patient privacy in traditional healthcare settings.

This leaves a big privacy gap for users.

Many consumer health apps don’t have the same strict regulations, so your personal health data might not be as safe as you think.

Real-World Privacy Violations

Here are a couple of examples that show the risks:

1. The Calmara Case

Calmara lets users upload photos for AI-powered STI detection.

Despite claiming to be HIPAA-compliant, their privacy policy says they share user data with a range of service providers.

This shows how apps can use the lack of clear rules to share sensitive information without fully informing users.

2. Grok and Data Harvesting

Grok encourages users to upload medical scans to improve its AI.

But its privacy policy is vague about how it shares data with “related” companies.

Without clear regulations, it’s hard to know exactly how your data is used or who sees it.

Why Users Should Be Cautious

Because many health apps aren’t regulated, users need to be extra careful. Here are a few tips to protect your privacy:

  • Check the Privacy Policy: Always read the privacy policy before using an app. Look for how it collects, uses, and shares your data. If it’s unclear or too broad, that’s a red flag.
  • Limit Data Sharing: Only share the information you really need to use the app. Think about whether the convenience of the app is worth the privacy risks.
  • Know the Limits: Remember, AI apps are not a replacement for professional medical advice. Always consult a healthcare provider before making decisions based on AI-generated information.
  • Support Stronger Regulations: Advocate for better privacy laws to protect health data in consumer apps. We need more transparency and control over our personal health information.

The lack of regulation for consumer health apps means your data could be used without your knowledge. Be cautious when sharing health information until stricter rules are in place.

Best Practices for Keeping Your Medical Data Private

Here are some simple steps you can take to keep your information safe:

1. Be Careful About What You Share

Think twice before providing too much information to health apps or AI tools.

Only share what’s necessary. For example, if an app just needs basic symptoms to suggest a diagnosis, there’s no need to share your entire medical history.

2. Check the Privacy Policy

Always read the privacy policy of health apps and AI tools.

Understand how they collect, store, and share your data. Be cautious if the policy includes vague terms or lets the app share your data with too many third parties.

3. Choose Secure Apps

Pick health apps that have strong security measures.

Look for features like encryption, secure logins, and clear data storage rules. Apps that are open about their data handling practices are usually safer.

4. Consult Healthcare Professionals

AI tools can assist, but they aren’t substitutes for a real doctor. If you have any concerns, always talk to a licensed healthcare provider. Relying on AI alone could lead to wrong advice.

5. Stay Updated

Keep yourself informed about the latest in AI and healthcare data privacy. As technology and regulations evolve, knowing the risks helps you make safer choices for your health data.

By following these simple steps, you can help protect your personal health information while using these new tools.

Why Data Privacy & Ethics Matter for Health-Tech Startups: Lessons from Calmara’s Missteps

Calmara’s STI detection app, using genital photos, highlights the critical importance of data privacy and ethics in health-tech. Despite its innovation, the company’s approach sparked controversy, offering key lessons for startups.

1. Vague Privacy Policies Damage Trust

Calmara’s privacy policy was criticized for being unclear.

It mentioned sharing data with “service providers and partners” but didn’t specify who these parties were or how they would use sensitive images.

This lack of transparency led to a loss of trust. For your startup, it’s vital to have clear, simple privacy policies.

Make sure users know exactly what data you’re collecting, how it’s being used, and who you’re sharing it with.

2. Marketing Must Be Honest

Calmara’s marketing misled users by promoting the product as a solution for “unprotected sex” without mentioning its limitations.

Health-tech startups must ensure their marketing is accurate, responsible, and never oversimplifies complex health issues.

3. Security Measures Are Critical

Calmara claimed to be HIPAA-compliant because they used Amazon Web Services (AWS), but just using a secure platform doesn’t guarantee data protection.

Startups need to implement their own strong security protocols. This includes data encryption, access controls, and clear data retention rules.

A data breach could result in legal fines, lawsuits, and damage to your reputation.

4. Ethics Should Guide Your Product Development

Calmara’s product raised serious ethical questions. Analyzing intimate photos of genitals without proper safeguards opens the door to potential misuse or data breaches.

As a health-tech entrepreneur, you must think carefully about the ethical implications of your product. If the risks outweigh the benefits, reconsider the product or service.

Why Data Privacy and Ethics Are Key for Success

1. Build User Trust

In healthcare, trust is everything. Users need to feel confident that their sensitive data is safe.

Prioritizing privacy and ethics builds that trust and helps your business grow.

2. Avoid Legal and Reputational Damage

Data breaches and privacy violations can lead to legal trouble, fines, and a tarnished reputation.

Strong security and ethical practices protect your business from these risks.

3. Uphold Your Responsibility

Health-tech companies handle sensitive data, and with that comes a moral responsibility to protect it.

Ethical practices ensure that your business contributes positively to the healthcare industry.

For a successful, sustainable health-tech business, prioritize user trust, security, and a strong ethical foundation.

Handling Sensitive Data in Healthcare Apps: What Developers and Startups Need to Know

1. Ensure HIPAA Compliance

Your app must comply with HIPAA and other privacy regulations like the GDPR.

This means protecting sensitive health data, including medical records, EHRs, and personal identifiers.

Data breaches can happen in any form—electronic, verbal, or written—so it’s crucial to understand the full scope of these laws.

2. Implement Strong Security Measures

Make sure sensitive data is securely stored and encrypted, both while it’s at rest and in transit.

Access controls are also key—only authorized personnel should have access to this information.

Using multi-factor authentication and role-based access controls is a good practice.

3. Be Transparent with Users

Clearly communicate how you collect, store, and share data.

Avoid jargon and be upfront about potential risks.

Always get explicit user consent before collecting or sharing their sensitive information.

Extra Considerations

  • AI and Data Privacy: As AI grows in healthcare apps, developers must ensure data is de-identified and user consent is obtained before it’s used in training models.
  • Continuous Vigilance: Stay updated on security threats and regularly adjust policies and practices to keep data protected.

Why Choose a Healthcare-Specific IT Vendor for Your Health-Tech Startup?

When you’re building a health-tech app or platform, it’s important to work with an IT vendor that specializes in healthcare.

Why? Healthcare IT vendors know the ins and outs of healthcare compliance, which general IT companies may not fully understand.

They’re experts in the rules like HIPAA and PIPEDA that protect patient data. These vendors also have real experience with AI projects.

AI in healthcare can be tricky.

While many companies say they know how to handle AI, only healthcare-specific vendors can guide you through the complexities.

If you don’t have the right expertise, your product could run into privacy issues or security problems.

By choosing a healthcare-focused IT company, you’re protecting your product and ensuring it’s built the right way, with all the necessary safeguards in place.

Meet our compliance experts and get a free consultation on building a secure healthtech solution